Plain backs of weathered limestone grave markers in a peaceful green burial garden beneath autumn trees.

What's Inside the Old Bearden Chapel on Kingston Pike, and What's Behind It

November 19, 2026

The old church building at 5902 Kingston Pike sits near Pelican's SnoBalls and Sitar Indian Cuisine. It had its grand opening on Nov. 1 as Saint Clare Collective. Allie Fleming founded the gift shop. A year and a half ago the site had a different plan. In June 2025, the Knoxville-Knox County Planning Commission approved a Taco Bell with a drive-thru there.

The small cemetery behind the building is the reason that approval came with conditions. You can't see it from Kingston Pike, and it has a history of its own.

The Pews Stayed, and Now They Hold Merchandise

Fleming worked with her husband, their four children, other family members and friends to renovate the chapel. They kept the original church pews and bookshelves and built the shop around them. The store is named for Saint Clare of Assisi.

According to Knox News, the shop sells both religious and general merchandise. Shelves carry books, crosses, rosaries, nativities, Advent wreaths and devotional candles. They also carry home décor, women's clothing, jewelry, Vols items, toys, vintage pieces and work by local makers. KnoxTNToday reports that a section called Lantern & Lily holds vintage finds and one-of-a-kind pieces collected around East Tennessee. The inventory also includes gifts for baptisms, First Communion and weddings, plus holiday decorations. Opening in November means the store's first full season is the holidays.

Part of the reason for the shop is a gap left in 2024, when The Paraclete closed. That was Knoxville's longtime Catholic bookstore and gift shop, and it had been open for 37 years. Fleming has said the store is for anyone who walks in. She told Knox News:

"We welcome people of all and any faiths and none whatsoever who may want to browse our diverse selection."

A 1925 Building on a Site Used Since the 1880s

News coverage calls it an "1880s chapel." The planning record is more precise. A Knox Planning staff report says the original congregation, Bearden Christian Church, was founded in the 1880s. The current building is believed to date to 1925 and stands where the original church stood. So the site's history starts in the 1880s, and the walls you walk into today are about a century old.

The building has been several things since then:

  • 1880s: Bearden Christian Church is founded here, and burials start in the cemetery behind it.
  • 1925: The current church building is believed to go up on the original site.
  • 1920s: Burials in the cemetery stop.
  • Later decades: The building houses Korean Christian Church, and most recently a Brazilian jiu-jitsu studio.
  • 2017: A new owner buys the property to preserve the church and rent it out. A few special events are held there after some remodeling.
  • 2024: The chapel goes up for sale on the condition that the building be moved off the site.
  • 2025: Taco Bell files plans for a restaurant with a drive-thru.
  • Nov. 1, 2026: Saint Clare Collective has its grand opening in the restored chapel.

A building can be moved. The graves behind it are protected under state law, and they stayed part of every plan for the land.

The Drive-Thru Approval Had Ten Conditions

Taco Bell of America filed its request on April 28, 2025. It asked to use 5900 and 5902 Kingston Pike for a drive-through restaurant. The Planning Commission approved it with conditions on June 12, 2025, by a 10–1 vote. The staff report shows the existing buildings were proposed for demolition. The cemetery was to stay, with a fence around it.

Two of the ten conditions dealt with the graves. The first required the initial grading and stripping work to be done under a professional archaeologist's supervision, with a report submitted to Planning staff before the site could be disturbed further. Only the permits needed for that investigation could be issued ahead of it. If graves turned up outside the planned cemetery line, the boundary had to be expanded or the graves relocated through the legal process. The second condition required a 10-foot buffer around gravesites. In the end, the drive-thru was never built. The chapel stayed where it was, and a gift shop moved in.

The Cemetery Is Larger Than It Looks

The archaeology condition came from a careful read of aerial photos. The staff report calls the site Bearden Christian Cemetery and says it was active from the early 1880s into the 1920s. It also notes that little about the cemetery is documented online, especially where each grave is.

To work out the boundary, planning staff used Knox County's mapping system, KGIS. The earliest images sharp enough to show individual headstones date to 1985. Staff compared those with images from 2016 and 2020. Over that time the easternmost headstones had been moved west, which made the cemetery look smaller. Before 2020, several headstones stood outside the boundary later drawn on the site plan.

The direction of the graves also mattered. The report notes that graves in older church cemeteries usually run west to east, with the headstone at the west end. If that held here, the retaining wall on the cemetery's east side would sit inside the 10-foot buffer and would need to move farther east. Staff could not tell whether the old headstone positions marked the actual graves, so they recommended supervised digging instead of relying on the photos.

The same report notes that Tennessee law gives descendants a lasting right to visit any cemetery where their ancestors are buried. The report's full discussion of state cemetery law is in the June 2025 staff report. Today, as KnoxTNToday put it, "a gravesite remains behind the building."

The Volunteers Who Helped Save It

KnoxTNToday reported that members of Friends of Cavett Station volunteered in the early efforts to preserve the former Bearden Christian Church site. The nonprofit's own mission is caring for Mars Hill Cemetery at 438 Broome Road in West Hills.

The two cemeteries are separate places, and they are a short drive apart. The Knoxville History Project places Cavett's Station near Mars Hill Cemetery off Broome Road. The Friends of Cavett Station history ties the site to Alexander Cavett, who bought 640 acres on Sinking Creek in 1790, and to the attack at Cavett's Station on Sept. 25, 1793. A memorial placed in 1921 stands in Mars Hill Cemetery.

Terry Faulkner, a Friends of Cavett Station board member, told Knox News, "Too many historic buildings and traditions are torn down and erased. Saint Clare Collective is a lovely next chapter in the legacy of this historic Bearden chapel." Learn more about the surrounding area on our Bearden and Sequoyah Hills page. Our post on the Kingston Pike rug showroom that's becoming a gym covers another recent change on the same stretch of road.

Before You Stop In

  • Address: 5902 Kingston Pike, near Pelican's SnoBalls and Sitar Indian Cuisine.
  • Hours: Check Saint Clare Collective on Facebook and Instagram at @SaintClareCollective.
  • Parking: During the grand opening, extra parking was available across Kingston Pike at Bearden Shopping Center near Food City, and visitors were asked to use the crosswalk at Bearden Road.
  • The cemetery: It sits behind the former church building. Planning law requires a 10-foot undisturbed buffer around its graves.

Older properties on Kingston Pike often carry history that affects what an owner can do with them and what they're worth. If you own an older home in Bearden or anywhere in West Knoxville and want an honest picture of that, Jennifer Whicker combines appraisal-backed pricing with years of work in these neighborhoods. Request your free home valuation, and Jennifer will walk you through the numbers in person.

WORK WITH JENNIFER

With me, what you see is what you’ll get. I’ll give you honest advice, enable you to think outside the box, and will be patient and never pushy. I’ll help you with decision-making and advocating, and make sure everything is moving forward. Your peace of mind is my priority. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a seasoned seller, I’d love to be your Knoxville Realtor®.